Psuedoscientific Therapies: Some Warning Signs
(adapted from the American Arthritis Foundation)
*originally printed in Science in Autism Treatment,
Spring 1999.
-
High "success" rates
are claimed.
-
Rapid effects are promised.
-
The therapy is said to be effective
for many symptoms or disorders.
-
The "theory" behind
the therapy contradicts objective knowledge (and
sometimes, common sense).
-
The therapy is said to be easy
to administer, requiring little training or expertise.
-
Other, proven treatments are said
to be unnecessary, inferior, or harmful.
-
Promoters of the therapy are working
outside their area of expertise.
-
Promoters benefit financially
or otherwise from adoption of the therapy.
-
Testimonials, anecdotes, or personal
accounts are offered in support of claims about
the therapy's effectiveness, but little or no
objective evidence is provided.
-
Catchy, emotionally appealing
slogans are used in marketing the therapy.
-
Belief and faith are said to be
necessary for the therapy to "work."
-
Skepticism and critical evaluation
are said to make the therapy's effects evaporate.
-
Promoters resist objective evaluation
and scrutiny of the therapy by others.
-
Negative findings from scientific
studies are ignored or dismissed.
-
Critics and scientific investigators
are often met with hostility, and are accused
of persecuting the promoters, being "close-minded,"
or having some ulterior motive for "debunking"
the therapy.
|